The High Cost of College – The $40K Club Gives Way to $50K
Tuesday, November 10th, 2009Once upon a time, the price of a year of schooling at elite private colleges matched the price of the average new car – not any more.
The news from The Chronicle of Higher Education certainly was not positive for students and families. After surveying private schools as to the charges for a year of attendance (tuition, fees, room and board), The Chronicle revealed that 58 private colleges had passed the 50K pricing milestone for 2009-2010.
Leading the way was one of the perennial front-runners, Sarah Lawrence College, at $55,788. Rounding out the top five were Landmark College, a school for students with learning disabilities ($53,900), Georgetown University ($52,161), New York University ($51,993), and George Washington University ($51,775).
Not Actually a New Barrier
While news, it is important to note that the $50K threshold had already been broken. It was just that a year ago, the Club had but five members.
And it is the calculus or rate of change for these numbers that is raising eyebrows. Ultimately, the sheer number of schools topping the threshold led The Chronicle to call $50K the new norm.
Amazingly, the $40K threshold once represented a major psychological milestone for many. But that figure has been rendered obsolete in the matter of just six years time.
In 2003, just two colleges set their tuition, fees, room, and board above $40,000. Including the members of the $50K club, 224 schools were above that threshold in 2009.
Unfortunately, reading the folks at The Chronicle, the average citizen may have even more bad news on the horizon. While some are wondering aloud if we are not on the edge of a precipice, others insist college prices are nowhere near a ceiling.
In fact, The Chronicle reports that “the most expensive institutions have seen no drop in demand.” Sadly, of these high costs, one school, Harvey Mudd, offered this assessment: “So long as we’re staying roughly in the same range, we don’t worry about it too much.”
Some Good News Exists
One positive in the midst of this data is that grants and other forms of financial aid help many students pay far less than the sticker price. Even more importantly, it seems that colleges have actually increased their financial aid at a faster rate than they have increased tuition and fees.
As one might expect, a large number of students receive need-based grants or merit-based scholarships with a significant amount of those funds come from the colleges themselves. The Chronicle was able to dissect data for 42 of the 58 colleges whose list price was more than $50,000 for 2009-10.
For 2008-2009, the average grant per full-time student was just over $13,000 – that meant that the “average bill last year for tuition, fees, room, and board, after grants, was about $36,000.”
However, the best news might be that some of these elite private schools are beginning to become concerned. Leadership at one of the schools that has become a member of the $50K club, Bryn Mawr, revealed they were “concerned because we fear the loss of access for students who deserve this education but might be priced out of it.” It should be noted that Bryn Mawr appears serious on both ends having offered an average grant package of about $30,000 last year.
$50K Too Pricey
But such figures also mask the real issue, that the costs of college are soaring at a rate that is unsustainable for the average student. And the clearest sign that $50K should flat out be considered too much is to return to the once relatively firm, age-old equivalent for private schools.
A year of college at the elite private institutions, the total costs including tuition, fees, room and board, should match the sticker price of a new Chevrolet.
And that might well be the most telling fact as to where things stand today. As at least one interviewee told The Chronicle:
“You don’t have to pay $50,000 for a new Chevy these days.”
In other words, too many students are not thinking properly about the debt they are accruing.
Making only the minimum payments ensures you will be in debt for the longest possible time. Paying the typical minimum level for a $500 debt at current interest rates of 15-20 percent will keep you in debt for more than a decade, even if you never charge another item.
However, you have probably heard on television or seen online an ad by some third party company that can help you eliminate your debt. While there are legitimate agencies that do provide such services, many other entities are simply hoping to take advantage of your plight. If you are not careful, you may soon find one of these companies is bleeding you worse than your credit card company.
For years, the generally accepted figure associated with earning a college diploma has been $1 million. Those calculated additional earnings a college graduate earns in his lifetime above and beyond of a classmate with just a high school diploma continue to be used as the rationale for earning that coveted diploma.
As a monetary investment that number still seems reasonable. We certainly can advocate spending $60,000 knowing full well we can one day expect to pocket $280,000 as a result. Add in the ability to better control one’s career choice and the investment seems to be a no-brainer.
At the university level, you will also meet many interesting people and have access to adults who are willing to help you learn new things. Once in the world of work, there will be far fewer people willing to help you become successful.
Under the IBR plan, the loans eligible for consideration include: all Federal Direct Loans (FDL) and federally guaranteed loans (FFEL) including subsidized and unsubsidized Federal Stafford loans; Federal Grad PLUS loans (but not Parent PLUS loans); and Federal Direct Consolidation loans. Federal Perkins Loans are only eligible when part of a Federal Direct Consolidation Loan.
The time period for public service is retroactive to October 1, 2007 meaning those borrowers who have already elected public service may begin counting the ten year period at that point. Some restrictions occur for those who had already consolidated their loans and those restrictions may move the eligible period forward to July 1, 2008.
One of the changes makes great sense, limiting credit lines to a student’s ability to pay makes perfect sense. But the changes will make credit more difficult to obtain for all individuals.
While those two numbers could be open for debate, such a design makes great sense. First and foremost, it allows low-income individuals limited access to credit even without a cosigner. Second, it would help students get started on a path to learning how to use a card without placing their future at significant risk.
However, one group of critics insists that the costs of the new protections will be passed on to more reliable credit card holders. A second group of naysayers stipulates that some of the biggest issues have simply not been addressed.
The 11-year deal provides the Michigan Alumni Association 0.5% of the total purchases made using one of the school-branded cards. Therefore, the school has an incentive for students to acquire and use a specific credit card.
Finishing just one semester early means a significant reduction in non-tuition costs, eliminating one semester of room and board and academic-related fees. Being able to take a semester off during the four-year period also gives students a chance to work full time to earn funds and thus reduce the amount of money that must be borrowed.
One of the more interesting developments is that the more selective a school is, the greater chance a school will “meet 100 percent of a family’s need.” Here again, only students with strong credentials will be considered at these colleges, so high-achievers are the ones most likely to secure additional funds.
While it is far more enjoyable to ease through four years of college study with a focus entirely on academics and your social life, the simplest way to minimizing debt is to work when you can.
If choosing a dream college means borrowing then you should rethink your choice. State universities offer quality educational options often at half the price.
Select one card based on its cash back or reduced-expenditure percentage that makes sense for you. Some cards reduce gas purchases by a nickel a gallon, others offer cash back on all online purchases, still others offer travel benefit options.
The result is that credit card users are overpaying for college big time. Unless a student pays off his or her card in full, by placing these charges on a credit card he or she is paying far more than the list price for books, fees and tuition.