In a 5 to 4 Vote the Supreme Court Undermines Brown vs Board of Education
Thursday, June 28th, 2007Recently the Supreme Court has settled a large number of cases with 5 to 4 votes divided on ideological lines. Today they decided the outcome of a lawsuit filed by a group of Seattle parents called the Parents Involved in Community Schools, which aimed to stop pushing desegregation by lessening the extent race places in admissions programs.
This new decision does not overtly support segregation, or discrimination, but the view of the outcome depends largely on your political views. Some liberals believe that this will push economic discrimination. Here is the liberal view from a WSJ article
Justice Breyer, in his dissent, said the high court is undermining the landmark school desegregation case Brown v. Board of Education. Reading vast parts of his dissent from the bench, Justice Breyer offered a scathing criticism of the four justices who would have found the admissions policies unconstitutional.
“It reverses course and reaches the wrong conclusion,” Justice Breyer wrote. “It distorts precedent, it misapplies the relevant constitutional principles, it announces legal rules that will obstruct efforts by state and local governments to deal effectively with the growing resegregation of public schools.”
And, in some cases, people claiming to be conservative are already quoting Martin Luther King’s I have a Dream
I have a dream that my four little children will one day live in a nation where they will not be judged by the color of their skin but by the content of their character.
Think Progress cited a study which shows that desegregation was the most effective way to close the gap. When courts determine laws based on their ideological lines and rewrite history with a stroke of a pen the fruits from years of struggle are lost. Since there were 5 conservatives on the Supreme Court bench they got their way - right or wrong. Over time, if we continue to move in this direction, perhaps college financial aid opportunities may also shift.
